Welcome to Carrot Juice
Looking for information about
carrot juice and juicing? Click here!
Home · Blogs · Recipes · Personals · Your Account · Forums 


icon_home.gif HomeShow/Hide content
tree-T.gif Privacy Statement
Access restricted to our members Calendar of Events
tree-T.gif Donations
tree-T.gif Why I am vegan
tree-L.gif Ethical vegetarian?
· Shop
icon_community.gif DiscussionsShow/Hide content
Access restricted to our members Private Messages
favoritos.gif NewsShow/Hide content
Access restricted to our members Submit News
tree-T.gif Topics
tree-T.gif Stories Archive
tree-T.gif AvantGo
tree-T.gif Animal rights and veg news feeds
tree-L.gif Submit an event to the calendar
som_downloads.gif LinksShow/Hide content
Access restricted to our members Downloads
tree-T.gif Web Links
tree-T.gif Submit a link
tree-L.gif link_to_us
icon_poll.gif ContentShow/Hide content
tree-T.gif Surveys
tree-T.gif Top 10
tree-T.gif Search
tree-T.gif FAQ
icon_members.gif Member ToolsShow/Hide content
Access restricted to our members Members List
tree-T.gif Statistics
tree-T.gif blogs / journals
tree-L.gif personals
email-y.gif ContactShow/Hide content
tree-T.gif Contact
tree-L.gif Recommend Us
recipe.gif FoodShow/Hide content
tree-T.gif Recipes

Donat o Meter

You do not need a Paypal account to donate.
Make donations with PayPal!
Donat-o-Meter Stats

August´s Goal: $20.00
Due Date: Aug 31
Amount in: $0.00
Balance: $0.00
Left to go: $20.00


User Info

Your IP:

Welcome, Anonymous
Security Code:
Security Code
Type Security Code:

· Register
· Lost Password
People Online:
Visitors: 71
Members: 0

We received
page views since
February 18, 2004







There isn't content right now for this block.


Support this site by buying Logo Products
See More Items...

Sell Your Own Logo Items

link to us

Link To Us

If you enjoy this site, tell a friend about us. Copy & Paste the code below to use our button.

Carrot Juice - Drink your juice daily!

See more here:

Thank You!

  Is it wrong to kick a robotic dog?
Posted on Tuesday, March 09 @ 15:41:54 EST by c0c0c0

Animal rights By Jeffrey MacDonald
March 10, 2004

When pet Lila wasn't getting as much playtime as the other two animals in her Plymouth, Massachusetts, home, owner Genie Boutchia felt guilty.

Then when a potential new owner came calling with $US850 ($A1120) in hand, Boutchia felt even guiltier. She changed her mind and deemed Lila not for sale.

Such feelings of moral responsibility might seem normal, even admirable, in a dog owner. But Lila is not a real dog. She's a robot.

And like tens of thousands like her in homes from Houston to Hong Kong, she's provoking fresh questions about who deserves moral treatment and respect.

How should people treat creatures that seem ever more emotional with each step forward in robotic technology, but who really have no feelings?

"Intellectually, you realise they don't have feelings, but you do imbue them with personality over time, so you are protective of them," Boutchia says.

"You feel guilty when you play with the other two dogs (which, as newer models, are more apparently emotive), even though you know Lila could not care less."

Trouble is, Lila seems to care, and her newer kin seem to care even more.

Sony Corp has brought the latest robotic engineering technology to bear on the new Aibo ERS-7, which at $US1599 ($A2100) promises to have six emotions: happiness, anger, fear, sadness, surprise, and discontent. Pat one on the head, and it becomes happy enough to do tricks.

Whack its nose, and it not only appears hurt, but it also learns not to repeat certain behaviour.

Aibo's "feelings" appear real enough that researchers at the University of Washington felt compelled to explain in a study that, contrary to Sony's claim, Aibo does not have any true emotions.

If Aibo did have true emotions and self-awareness, philosophers generally agree, then it would require humane treatment.

But as machines, robotic pets with sad eyes can nevertheless be legitimately neglected, a fact that some people find troubling, while others welcome both in its practicality and moral significance.

Among those celebrating the ability to forget a pet without consequence is a national animal rights group, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA).

"The turn toward having robotic animals in place of real animals is a step in the right direction," says PETA spokeswoman Lisa Lange. "It shows a person's recognition that they aren't up to the commitment of caring for a real animal. Practically speaking, from PETA's perspective, it really doesn't matter what you do to a tin object."

A trend that might be good for animals, however, might not be good for those who profit most from relationships with animals, according to Peter Kahn, a psychology professor at the University of Washington who has studied Aibo's effect on preschoolers at the university's Centre for Mind, Brain and Learning.

"Children need rich interactions with real, sentient others, both human and animals," Professor Kahn says.

"If we replace that, I think we're impoverishing our children. These relationships (with robotic pets) aren't going to be fully moral. They'll be partially moral, which is not as good as a real relationship with a real animal whose needs teach children that their own desires don't always come first."

Despite their attachments, most Aibo owners don't seem to grant their pets much moral standing, according to sociological research done by Kahn and his colleague, Professor Batya Friedman.

Fewer than 10 per cent of owners who openly shared their feelings in an online chatroom indicated a belief that their pet had rights or could be blamed for misdoings.

Owners always seem to remember, whether on a conscious or subconscious level, that their pets - beloved as they are - remain machines.

Nevertheless, some are more comfortable than others with treating them as mere machinery.

For Peter Danielson, director of the Centre for Applied Ethics at the University of British Columbia, the danger lies not in regarding mechanical pets too lowly but rather too highly.

They are, after all, not much different from handheld computers.

"If someone puts a (robotic) kitten in a microwave, it's not horrible. It's foolish, but it's not morally forbidden," Danielson says.

"It seems to me there's a whole ethics of fiction and toys that we're thinking through. Are you telling me I ought to treat something that looks like a kitten, but is actually a piece of plastic, better than I treat a pig, which is actually a sentient and intelligent being? You're building a taboo system that gets further and further from the actual value. And every time you do that, you lose your moral authority with your technologically inclined kid who says, 'That's stupid'."

Yet for those who ascribe emotions to a robotic pet, and who learn nonetheless that they can be neglected or abused without consequence, a dangerous habit with larger implications could be in the works, according to James Hughes, a sociologist at Trinity College in Hartford, Connecticut, and secretary of the World Transhumanist Association.

"The concern is that treating an 'animal' as a lesser being could bleed over to treating certain humans as lesser beings," Hughes says.

Consider a human being in a vegetative state with no greater self-awareness or deep desires than a robotic pet, he says.

If Aibo deserves no respect because it lacks self-awareness and deep desires, he asks, then on what basis would a vegetative human being deserve any measure of respect?

Even if a robot is "abused," it may not "hurt" the object, but the act of destruction shows a lack of respect for property.

"We have to become more sophisticated in the distinctions we make in order to ensure we make them responsibly," Hughes says.

The Christian Science Monitor News Service


Article's Poll

Is it wrong to kick a robotic dog?

I don't know
maybe in a few years
no opinion

[ Results | Polls ]

Number of votes 13

Related Links

· More about Animal rights
· News by c0c0c0

Most read Animal rights:
Animal Cruelty at Orthodox Monastery in Russia


Article Rating

Average score: 0
Number of votes: 0

Please take a second and vote for this article:

Very Good



 Printer Friendly Printer Friendly


Associated Topics


All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner.
The comments are property of their posters, all the rest © 2004 - 2010 by Carrot Juice.
You can syndicate our news using the file backend.php or ultramode.txt our forums here:backendforums.php
Please read and understand our Privacy statement.

Fair Use Notice: This document may contain copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owners. We believe that this not-for-profit, educational use on the Web constitutes a fair use of the copyrighted material (as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law). If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond fair use, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
Website Promotion | CorelDRAW Keygen
PHP-Nuke Copyright © 2004 by Francisco Burzi. This is free software, and you may redistribute it under the GPL. PHP-Nuke comes with absolutely no warranty, for details, see the license.
Page Generation: 0.07 Seconds